1940
Elisabeth Sanxay Holding: The Girl Who Had to Die
Dorothy B. Hughes: The So Blue Marble
Dorothy B. Hughes: The Cross-Eyed Bear
1941
Elisabeth Sanxay Holding: Speak of the Devil
Lenore Glen Offord: The Nine Dark Hours
1942
Elisabeth Sanxay Holding: Kill Joy
Elisabeth Sanxay Holding: Lady Killer
Dorothy B. Hughes: The Fallen Sparrow
1943
Charlotte Armstrong: The Case of the Weird Sisters
Elisabeth Sanxay Holding: The Old Battle Ax
Dorothy B. Hughes: The Blackbirder
Margaret Millar: Wall of Eyes
Lenore Glen Offord: Skeleton Key
1944
Leigh Brackett: No Good from a Corpse
Dorothy B. Hughes: The Delicate Ape
Margaret Millar: Fire Will Freeze
Craig Rice: Home Sweet Homicide
1945
Vera Caspary: Bedelia
Elisabeth Sanxay Holding: Net of Cobwebs
M. V. Heberden: Vicious Pattern
Dorothy B. Hughes: Dread Journey
Margaret Millar: The Iron Gates
1946
Charlotte Armstrong: The Unsuspected
Helen Eustis: The Horizontal Man
Elisabeth Sanxay Holding: The Innocent Mrs. Duff
Dorothy B. Hughes: Ride the Pink Horse
1947
M. V. Heberden: They Can’t All Be Guilty
Dorothy B. Hughes: In a Lonely Place
Elisabeth Sanxay Holding: The Blank Wall
Hilda Lawrence: The House
Lenore Glen Offord: My True Love Lies
1948
Charlotte Armstrong: The Chocolate Cobweb
Mildred B. Davis: The Room Upstairs
Edna Sherry: Sudden Fear
1949
Dorothy Salisbury Davis: The Judas Cat
Juanita Sheridan: The Chinese Shop
1950
Patricia Highsmith: Strangers on a Train
Dorothy B. Hughes: The Candy Kid
Dana Lyon: The Tentacles
Margaret Millar: Do Evil in Return
1951
Dorothy Salisbury Davis: A Gentle Murderer
M. V. Heberden: The Sleeping Witness
Elisabeth Sanxay Holding: Too Many Bottles
Elisabeth Sanxay Holding: The Virgin Huntress
Helen Nielsen: The Kind Man
Juanita Sheridan: The Kahuna Killer
1952
Dorothy Salisbury Davis: The Clay Hand
Dorothy Salisbury Davis: A Town of Masks
Dolores Hitchens: Nets to Catch the Wind
Dorothy B. Hughes: The Davidian Report
Margaret Millar: Rose’s Last Summer
Margaret Millar: Vanish in an Instant
Helen Nielsen: Gold Coast Nocturne
Helen Nielsen: Obit Delayed
Juanita Sheridan: The Mamo Murders
Nedra Tyre: Mouse in Eternity
1953
Mildred B. Davis: They Buried A Man
Elisabeth Sanxay Holding: Widow’s Mite
Helen Nielsen: Detour
Juanita Sheridan: The Waikiki Widow
1954
Helen Eustis: The Fool Killer
Dolores Hitchens: Beat Back the Tide
Helen Nielsen: The Woman on the Roof
Jean Potts: Go, Lovely Rose
Patricia Highsmith: The Blunderer
Holly Roth: The Mask of Glass
1955
Charlotte Armstrong: The Dream Walker
Dolores Hitchens: Sleep with Strangers
Margaret Millar: Beast In View
Helen Nielsen: Stranger in the Dark
Patricia Highsmith: The Talented Mr. Ripley
Holly Roth: The Sleeper
1956
Charlotte Armstrong: A Dram of Poison
Margot Bennett: The Man Who Didn’t Fly
Jean Potts: The Diehard
Helen Nielsen: The Crime Is Murder
Edna Sherry: Backfire
1957
Leigh Brackett: An Eye for an Eye
Leigh Brackett: Tiger Among Us
Elizabeth Fenwick: Poor Harriet
Margaret Millar: An Air That Kills
Helen Nielsen: Borrow the Night
Evelyn Piper: Bunny Lake Is Missing
Patricia Highsmith: Deep Water
1958
Jean Potts: Lightning Strikes Twice
Patricia Highsmith: A Game for the Living
1959
Elizabeth Fenwick: A Long Way Down
Dolores Hitchens: The Watcher
Margaret Millar: The Listening Walls
Helen Nielsen: The Fifth Caller
Helen Nielsen: False Witness
Lenore Glen Offord: Walking Shadow
1960
Dolores Hitchens: Sleep with Slander
Margaret Millar: A Stranger in My Grave
Helen Nielsen: Sing Me a Murder
Holly Roth (as K. G. Ballard): Bar Sinister
Nedra Tyre: Hall of Death
Patricia Highsmith: This Sweet Sickness
1961
Anne Blaidsell: Nightmare
Suzanne Blanc: The Green Stone
Dolores Hitchens: Footsteps in the Night
Vin Packer: Something in the Shadows
1962
Charlotte Armstrong: Something Blue
Dolores Hitchens: The Abductor
Margaret Millar: How Like an Angel
Vin Packer: Intimate Victims
Jean Potts: The Evil Wish
Patricia Highsmith: The Cry of the Owl
1963
Charlotte Armstrong: A Little Less Than Kind
Elizabeth Fenwick: The Make-Believe Man
Dorothy B. Hughes: The Expendable Man
Dana Lyon: Spin the Web Tight
1964
Amanda Cross: In The Last Analysis
Mildred B. Davis: The Voice on the Telephone
Emma Lathen: Accounting For Murder
Dana Lyon: The Trusting Victim
Margaret Millar: The Fiend
Helen Nielsen: Verdict Suspended
Patricia Highsmith: The Two Faces of January
Patricia Highsmith: The Glass Cell
1965
Dorothy Salisbury Davis: The Pale Betrayer
Patricia Highsmith: The Story-Teller
Dolores Hitchens (as Dolan Birkley): The Unloved
1966
Lilian Jackson Braun: The Cat Who Read Backwards
Mildred B. Davis: The Sounds of Insects
Lois Duncan: Point of Violence
Dorothy Gilman: The Unexpected Mrs. Pollifax
Helen Nielsen: After Midnight
Jean Potts: The Footsteps on the Stairs
1967
Charlotte Armstrong: The Gift Shop
Amanda Cross: The James Joyce Murder
Mildred B. Davis: Strange Corner
Mildred B. Davis: Walk Into Yesterday
Emma Lathen: Murder Against the Grain
Helen Nielsen: A Killer in the Street
Patricia Highsmith: Those Who Walk Away
1968
Charlotte Armstrong: The Balloon Man
Charlotte Armstrong: Lemon in the Basket
Jean Potts: The Little Lie
Dorothy Uhnak: The Bait
1969
Dorothy Salisbury Davis: Where the Dark Streets Go
Patricia Highsmith: The Tremor of Forgery
Emma Lathen: When In Greece
Dorothy Uhnak: The Witness
1970
Amanda Cross: Poetic Justice
Margaret Millar: Beyond This Point Are Monsters
Patricia Highsmith: Ripley Under Ground
Dorothy Uhnak: The Ledger
1971
Nedra Tyre: Twice So Fair
1972
Dorothy Salisbury Davis: Shock Wave
1973
Dorothy Salisbury Davis: The Little Brothers
1974
Patricia Highsmith: Ripley’s Game
1975
Mary Higgins Clark: Where Are The Children?
Mildred B. Davis: Tell Them What’s-Her-Name Called